When Safety Isn’t Safe: A Glimpse Into Protecting His Heart

Some moments in a story hit so hard you can feel the breath leave your own lungs. This scene from Protecting His Heart is one of those turning points—the instant when everything Rachel thought she had under control begins to crack… and the one man she never expected steps into the light.

Until now, Rachel has done everything right. She’s stayed quiet. Agreeable. Hidden behind “I’m fine.”

Enter Ian McCleary—the steady, soft-spoken officer with eyes that notice too much and a heart that refuses to look away. Their first accidental spark months ago was nothing compared to this collision: a dangerous boyfriend, a crowded bar, one violent swing that exposes more than bruises.

In the scene below, Rachel’s world tilts—toward fear, toward honesty, and toward a man who will risk everything to protect a woman who insists she doesn’t need protecting.

If you love emotionally charged romance, quiet heroes, high-stakes tension, and heroines on the brink of reclaiming their strength… this is for you.

“Rachel.”

The voice was familiar, but the light touch on her shoulder still made her flinch and her heart jerk in her chest. She turned, expecting—

Not Josh.

Ian McCleary.

Relief rippled through her so fast it almost knocked the air out of her lungs. Her eyes met his—those amber eyes she hadn’t been able to forget since the bachelorette party last summer. There’d been something about him that night… the way he’d listened, like she mattered. Like he saw her. She’d never talked that easily with a man before.

He was so nice.

Too nice.

And now, standing this close, he looked even better than she remembered. Instead of his police uniform, he wore a soft charcoal t-shirt that stretched across his chest, jeans that fit low and snug at the hips. His auburn hair was a little mussed, the longer strands falling onto his forehead, like he’d raked his hands through it on his way inside. The same color dusted his jawline in a short, trimmed beard. Paired with that serious expression he always wore, it made him look rougher than usual.

And oh, so handsome.

His eyes didn’t just look at her—they searched. Like he was trying to read every page of her heart. Like he already knew what he’d find.

“How are you?” he said.

She dropped her gaze, the weight of his attention making her feel like a smudged window someone had just cleaned. The memory of Halloween came roaring back—her black eye, the lie she’d told, the way she hadn’t been able to look him in the face then, either.

“I’m fine,” she said.

“And things with…?”

“Josh.” The name felt bitter in her mouth. Her eyes flicked toward the door. He’d only stepped outside for a few minutes…

“How are they?” Ian said.

She forced a smile. “Fine. Good.”

Ian didn’t look convinced. “I’ve been worried about you since I saw you at that party.”

“Oh that?” She gave a breathy laugh, too fast, too fake. “That was nothing. Just… the door. At the diner. It hit me.”

He nodded once, solemn. “So you said.”

She twisted the ring on her finger—cheap costume jewelry Josh insisted made her look ‘classy.’ Her voice wavered. “Ian, you can’t… we can’t do this. You shouldn’t even be talking to me.”

He didn’t move. Didn’t look away. “Why?” he said.

Her breath caught. Why? “Because… just…”

Ian tilted his head slightly, narrowing his gaze. “Because Josh might get mad?”

Her mouth went dry. God, yes. Josh would be furious, and she’d pay for it. Maybe not here, not in public. But later. When no one was looking.

But she couldn’t say that out loud. Saying it would make it real, and she wasn’t ready to look that truth in the face.

Movement flickered behind Ian, and the door swung open.

Oh no.

Josh appeared like a thundercloud, dark and fast. He grabbed Ian by the shoulder and spun him around so violently Rachel gasped.

“I thought I made it clear I don’t want you sniffin’ around my woman,” Josh snarled, his voice thick with booze and spite. Then he reared back and swung.

Ian dodged it like he saw it coming from a mile away.

Josh’s lip curled. “She listens to me, asshole. Not you.”

And that’s when she recognized what she saw in Ian’s expression—fury. Not the hot, chaotic kind Josh wore like a cologne, but something contained. Controlled. The kind of fury that came from years of witnessing injustice and finally drawing a line in the sand.

“She’s not a piece of property,” Ian said. “You don’t get to tell her what to do.”

Her breath caught.

“Josh, forget it,” she said, her voice cracking. “Come on. Let’s go somewhere else.” She tried to pull him away, but his body was rigid. Immovable.

“Let me say this slowly so you don’t miss it.” Ian’s voice dropped, calm as ice. “You don’t deserve her.”

Josh roared and swung again. This time his fist connected with Ian’s jaw with a sickening crack.

Rachel’s hands flew to her mouth, a cry choking in her throat.

Ian staggered back a step, but his balance held. He didn’t even blink. Then, quick as a whip, his fist snapped forward, landing squarely against the side of Josh’s head.

Josh’s shout turned into a bellow of rage. He lunged, wrapping both arms around Ian’s waist and trying to take him down in a messy tackle.

Ian held his ground.

Josh let go and flailed, his fists landing sloppily, one after the other, but Ian didn’t even flinch. He waited—just a few seconds—then punched Josh hard in the gut.

The air whooshed out of Josh’s lungs like a deflated tire. He collapsed to his knees, eyes wide and mouth working as he tried to suck in air.

“Break it up!” a new voice barked.

Rachel turned, disoriented. A uniformed officer pushed through the crowd and shoved himself between the men.

“Get up, you piece of shit!” Ian growled, his body trembling with restrained fury.

The officer got an arm across his chest. “McCleary? What the hell?”

Ian jerked away from the contact. “He took the first swing.”

The crowd murmured its agreement, and the cop gave a short nod. He looked down at Josh, still on his knees and wheezing, then reached down and hauled him to his feet.

“Pretty lit up too,” he said. “Reckon we need to give him a little time out.”

Ian didn’t answer. His eyes were on her. Not Josh. Not the officer. Not the crowd still murmuring in shocked whispers.

He was checking her face. Her eyes. Like he needed to make sure she was still whole.

Her legs trembled. Hands grabbed her—friends? strangers?—pulling her back as the officer cuffed Josh and began hauling him out of the bar.

Josh screamed curses, spit flying, his voice slurred and venomous.

She just stood there, stunned.

He hit Ian. And Ian hit back. For me.

Across the room, Leo shoved the kitchen door open and pushed Ian through it, out of sight.

Rachel hovered near the edge of the crowd, her pulse still racing. Josh’s angry curses faded into the frigid night, but the memory of his fist slamming into Ian’s jaw lingered like a punch to her gut.

Why had Ian done that?

Around her, voices rose in excited murmurs, people dissecting the fight, placing bets on who threw the harder punch. Rachel didn’t care. Her eyes were locked on the swinging kitchen door at the back of the bar.

How dare he get her boyfriend arrested! Hadn’t she told Ian to leave her alone?

She shouldn’t go back there.

But her feet moved anyway.

The scent of fried food and beer lingered in the air as she pushed through the kitchen door. The heat was stronger back here, tinged with grease and the sharp tang of disinfectant.

Rachel blinked and focused on the person sitting on a low stool by the prep counter.

Ian.

His body was hunched forward, elbows resting on his knees. One hand cradled an ice pack against the side of his face. Blood smeared the corner of his mouth.

She clung to her anger like a shield, arms crossed tight across her chest, but her resolve was already weakening, because beneath the anger was something far more dangerous.

Worry.

Ian was hurt.

And he’d gotten hurt because of her.

Her chest twisted. She should turn around. Walk away.

But she didn’t.

Ian’s chin lifted slowly, the movement deliberate. His amber eyes met hers, calm and unflinching.

“It’s one night he won’t be able to hurt you,” he said.

The words hit her like a slap—too close, too accurate, too real—and her mouth dropped open.

He couldn’t know. Could he?

She’d been so careful. Always covering up, always making excuses, always smiling at the right moments so no one would notice. No one could possibly know what happened behind closed doors.

Rachel’s throat constricted. She opened her mouth to deny his words, to say That’s not true, He didn’t mean it, It’s not what you think. But before the words could form, a waitress bustled in from the bar, holding a shot glass filled to the brim with amber liquid.

“Here, honey,” the waitress said, thrusting the glass toward Ian. “This’ll take the edge off. On the house.”

Then, from behind her, another voice burst through the door. “Rachel!”

Rachel took a step back, wishing she could erase the heat crawling up her neck.

Her friend Kathy appeared at her side, grabbing her elbow. “What are you doing in here?” she hissed.

From the corner, Leo grunted something about too many people in his goddamn kitchen.

“You poor thing,” Kathy said, gripping Rachel like she might vanish. “Come on. Let’s get out of here.”

Rachel didn’t resist.

She let Kathy lead her, stumbling slightly as they moved through the door and back into the relative safety of the bar.

But even as the lights dimmed and the noise swallowed her, she couldn’t stop thinking about the way Ian had looked at her.

Not with pity.

Not with judgment.

Just quiet, steady understanding.

And Rachel knew she’d never forget the look in his eyes.

Because Ian McCleary knew.

Ready to keep reading? Order directly from me and SAVE. Or get it at your favorite e-tailer.

Want freebies and sneak peeks sent right to your in-box? Subscribe here!